# Procedural democracy versus customary deliberation: the scholarly debate on Papua’s noken electoral system > Miram E. URL kanonis: https://discover.unhas.ac.id/publications/pub_scopus_105055305735 Jurnal / Konferensi: Frontiers in Political Science Tahun terbit: 2026 DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpos.2026.1893764 ISSN: 26733145 Kuartil SJR: Q1 Citations: 0 ## Authors - Miram E. ## Abstract The Indonesian Constitutional Court’s 2009 recognition of the noken system—a traditional collective voting practice in highland Papua—as a valid alternative to one person, one vote has sparked an unresolved scholarly debate. Despite a growing literature, the field remains fragmented, and no review has systematically mapped its principal schools of thought. This mini review addresses this gap through a Scopus keyword search on “noken” (2013–2026) returning twenty-two documents. After screening out fifteen that address noken as material culture rather than as an electoral institution, and adding three foundational works via citation chaining, an analytic corpus of ten documents was thematically coded. Three competing interpretations emerge. The procedural-liberal interpretation treats noken as a constitutional exception with contested compatibility with universal suffrage and human rights standards. The deliberative-customary interpretation defends it as an authentic, locally rooted democratic form legitimated through musyawarah and communal recognition. The critical-governance interpretation suspends the normative question, treating noken as a politically ambivalent institution whose democratic quality depends on enforcement and elite influence. These readings are complementary investigations of a hybrid political institution; four research gaps and five future directions—centered on district-level ethnography, gender, and Global South comparison—are outlined. ## Keywords - Interpretation (philosophy) - Democracy - Political science - Voting - Politics - Elite - Law - Suffrage - Citation - Normative - Sociology - Enforcement - Law and economics - Universal suffrage - Consolidation (business) - Political anthropology - Public administration - Judicial interpretation - Ambivalence - Presidential system - Political culture - Human rights - Political economy - Opposition (politics) - Polity - Indonesian - Constitutional amendment - Democratic consolidation - Merge (version control) - Field (mathematics) - Caste - Representative democracy - Ideology - Scholarship - Principal (computer security) - Commission - Institution --- Sumber: Discover Unhas — RIMS Universitas Hasanuddin. Saat mengutip, gunakan DOI bila tersedia atau URL kanonis di atas.